Edinburgh's Old Town is not a historic district in the way that term is usually meant — a preserved quarter maintained for visitors. It is a living accumulation. The medieval street plan survives because the terrain made rebuilding impractical. The closes run where they do because of geology, not planning. The result is that walking the Royal Mile is genuinely different from walking through a recreated history — the architecture, the geography, and the stories are all authentically connected to each other. This guide covers what happened here and why it still matters.
Edinburgh's Old Town exists on a crag-and-tail formation — a geological structure created when the last ice age's glaciers met a volcanic plug of hard basalt rock. The glacier split around the rock, eroding the softer sandstone on either side. What remained was a ridge: the hard volcanic rock at the western end, now occupied by Edinburgh Castle, and a long tail of ground descending eastward to the present-day Holyroodhouse.
This topography made the site naturally defensible. The castle sits on a near-vertical cliff on three sides. The ridge provided a single line of development that could be defended from the castle. It also meant the city had nowhere to expand except upward — the pressure of population within the defensive walls produced some of the earliest high-rise housing in the world. By the 17th century, Edinburgh's tenements were reaching nine and ten storeys, housing thousands of people in extraordinary proximity.
The closes and wynds that branch off the Royal Mile follow the natural geography — they descend the ridge on either side, following the fall of the land down to the Cowgate in the south and the Nor' Loch (now Princes Street Gardens) to the north. Many of them are named for the trades or families that occupied them, preserving records of Edinburgh's social history in their names.
Edinburgh granted royal burgh status under David I. The castle, the Canongate, St Giles' Cathedral established. Population densely packed along the ridge.
John Knox and the Scottish Reformation. Mass witch persecution — Scotland executed more per capita than almost any European country. James VI personally attended trials.
Edinburgh became the Athens of the North. Hume, Smith, Boswell, Burns. The New Town constructed to relieve Old Town overcrowding.
Edinburgh's anatomy school created demand for cadavers. Burke and Hare murdered at least 16 people. The Anatomy Act of 1832 followed directly.
Edinburgh received its first royal charter as a burgh under David I of Scotland in the 12th century, though settlement on the Castle Rock almost certainly predates this by centuries. The burgh occupied the ridge between the castle and the Canongate — a separate, independently chartered burgh that extended east toward Holyrood Abbey, founded by David I in 1128.
St Giles' Cathedral, the High Kirk of Edinburgh, was built on the site of an earlier church during the 14th century. The building that stands today is largely 15th-century, though with significant later additions. It was the religious centre of the Old Town, and its churchyard — now Parliament Square — was used as a marketplace, a place of public punishment, and a general social gathering point. The Mercat Cross, which still stands nearby, was the official hub of royal proclamations and public executions.
The population within the defensive walls grew steadily. By the 15th century, Edinburgh was Scotland's primary trading city and one of its most significant political centres. The density that would come to characterise the Old Town was already beginning to develop — buildings rising higher as the pressure of population within the walls intensified.
The Scottish Reformation of 1560, led in Edinburgh primarily by John Knox, transformed the religious character of the city rapidly and completely. Knox preached at St Giles' Cathedral after its conversion to Protestant worship. The monastery at Holyrood, already in decline, was effectively destroyed. The burgh's relationship with the Catholic Church — which had structured much of its social and political life for centuries — was severed within a generation.
The period also produced one of the darkest chapters in Scottish history: the systematic prosecution and execution of people accused of witchcraft. Scotland's witch trials were extraordinarily intense by European standards. Between approximately 1590 and 1736, between 1,500 and 2,500 people were executed — the vast majority of them women — and Edinburgh was central to the persecution.
King James VI of Scotland (later James I of England) was personally and obsessively interested in witchcraft. His 1597 book Daemonologie was a serious treatise on the subject, and he attended and participated in some of the Edinburgh trials directly. The North Berwick witch trials of 1590–91, which he supervised personally, resulted in multiple executions and set the tone for the persecution that would continue for over a century.
The Castlehill area at the top of the Royal Mile was the primary site of Edinburgh witch burnings. A small ornamental fountain — the Witches Well, installed in 1894 — marks the spot today, an understated memorial to what happened on that ground.
The 18th century produced one of the most remarkable intellectual concentrations in European history, and Edinburgh was at its centre. The so-called Scottish Enlightenment brought together philosophers, economists, scientists, and writers in a city small enough that they all knew each other personally.
David Hume, whose philosophical scepticism remains among the most significant contributions to Western philosophy, lived for much of his life in Edinburgh. Adam Smith, whose Wealth of Nations (1776) effectively founded modern economics, was a regular presence in Edinburgh's intellectual circles despite his professorship in Glasgow. James Boswell, Robert Burns, and later Walter Scott all operated within the same compact social world.
The intellectual life of the Enlightenment was inseparable from the physical character of the Old Town. Edinburgh's closes and taverns — Anchor Close, where Burns drank with the Crochallan Fencibles; the taverns around the Grassmarket — were the social infrastructure that made the exchanges possible. The physical density of the city meant that the various Edinburgh clubs and societies that drove the Enlightenment were literally within walking distance of each other.
Edinburgh's medical school, founded in 1726, became one of the most important in the world by the late 18th century. But the legal supply of cadavers for anatomical study was inadequate — only the bodies of executed criminals could be used legally, and the demand from Edinburgh's growing anatomy classes far exceeded this supply. A black market in corpses developed as a result.
Body snatchers — known as resurrection men — operated in Edinburgh's graveyards, digging up freshly buried bodies and selling them to anatomy schools. Greyfriars Kirkyard was one of their primary targets. The iron mortsafes you can still see in the kirkyard were the community's response: locked iron cages placed over fresh graves to prevent removal of the body until it had decomposed enough to be useless for anatomy.
William Burke and William Hare took a more direct approach. Rather than disturbing graves, they murdered at least sixteen people in Edinburgh's West Port neighbourhood between 1827 and 1828 and sold the bodies to Dr Robert Knox's anatomy school. The case caused a national scandal. Burke was convicted and hanged in January 1829 — and then publicly dissected, in a grim piece of poetic justice. Hare turned King's evidence and was released. Knox was never prosecuted.
The scandal led directly to the Anatomy Act of 1832, which regularised the supply of cadavers by allowing unclaimed bodies from workhouses to be used for medical study. The supply of murder victims for anatomy schools ended, though not, one suspects, through any shortage of demand.
Our Ancient Legends & Hidden Closes tour is built around the documented history of the Old Town — the medieval street plan, the social history embedded in the closes, the Reformation's physical impact on the city, and the stories that don't appear in any guidebook because they require knowing where to look.
We visit closes that are unmarked on tourist maps. We explain the social geography that determined who lived where in Edinburgh's medieval tenements. We cover the Enlightenment's physical infrastructure — the taverns, the clubs, the geography of intellectual Edinburgh. The tour runs in daytime when the light is good and the closes are accessible, departing from Mercat Cross at 9:30, 11:30, 1:30, and 3:30.
90 minutes through Edinburgh's medieval heart — the closes that aren't on tourist maps, the social history of the Royal Mile, and the stories drawn from primary sources rather than guidebooks.
Book This Tour — £18 →Sign up and we'll send your discount code instantly. Plus: new guides, seasonal specials, and Edinburgh stories that don't make the guidebooks.